# JAVA Magic Square Problem

Recall that a magic square is a 2-dimensional square array with n rows and n columns where each row,

col, and diagonal add up to the same value. The value that every row, column, and diagonal adds up to is

called the magic sum. For example, here is a magic square for the case n = 4 with a magic sum of 34:

6 10 7 11 3 8 9 14 12 1 16 5 13 15 2 4

If a size n magic square contains all of the number from 1 to n2 exactly once (as in the example above) we

call this a standard magic square and it is not hard to show that the magic sum of a standard size n magic

square is n×(n2 +1)

2 .

You are to write a program that will find standard magic squares in three different ways, by

implementing the following 3 algorithms.

Purely random. Randomly put the numbers from 1 to n2 into an n × n array and then check to see if it is

a magic square. Fill the array from top to bottom, left to right order. In other words, first fill the first row

from left to right, then the second row, etc. Do this repeated until either a magic square is found or some

limit for the number of tries is reached. The limit will be a parameter to your magic square method.

The hardest part of implementing this is finding an efficient way to it. For example, in the 4 × 4 case,

how do we get the numbers from 1 to 16 randomly into the array? The way I did it was to create a 16

element array (in general you will create a n × n array) and put the numbers from 1 to 16 into that array. I

then randomly found one of the 16 elements, put it into the magic square array, and switched that element to

the end of the array so that I would never use it again. For the next step I randomly selected an element from

the first 15 spots in the array, put that in the magic sum array, and then swapped it so that it is 1 from the end

of the array.

Here’s how the example above got started. Let’s call my 16-element array num. It starts looking like this:

num: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16

The algorithm found a random location in the 16-element array, in this case it’s location 5 with value 6, put

the 6 in the first position of the magic square and then swapped that 6 with 16 at the end of the num array,

giving us:

num: 1 2 3 4 5 16 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 6

Next the algorithm found a random location in the first 15 spots of num, in this case it was 10 which was

then put into the magic square and moved to the right of num giving us:

num: 1 2 3 4 5 16 7 8 9 15 11 12 13 14 10 6

Continue this until the entire magic square array is filled.

If you have an alternative way for doing this bring it up in a Discussion.

For finding random numbers you can either use Math.random or the Random class. Look these up in the

Java docs here and here. I think the Random class is easier to use but just be sure not to instantiate too many

Random objects. You only need 1.

Last element of each row not random. This algorithm is the same as the purely random algorithm

except when placing an element at the end of the row do not choose randomly but select the only element

that works based on the magic sum. Looking at the 4 × 4 example above, the algorithm would have chosen

6, 10, and 7 randomly but now the only number that will work for the last spot is 11, so simply place that

number in that spot in the array. The implementation of this is going to be similar to the purely random one,

but you will need some addition code or methods to find the number for that last spot of each row. Don’t

forget that it might not always be possible to find that last value. For example, suppose the first 3 random

values put in the magic square array are 2, 3, and 5. Since the magic sum of a 4 × 4 array is 34 we would

need the value 24, but the largest number available is 16.

You should notice that this algorithm finds solutions much faster than the purely random one. In fact, my

purely random program only found solutions to n = 3 cases in a reasonable amount of time. n = 4 would

frequently take more than 100,000,000 tries. But n = 4 works well with this algorithm, finding solutions

quite quickly. The average number of tries necessary for this algorithm to find a magic square is just a little

over 5,000,000.

Pair heuristic. This only works for cases where n is even and I will describe it for the n = 4 case. Recall

that the magic sum for an n = 4 array is 34. Put elements randomly into the rows in pairs where each pair

sums to 17, ½ the magic sum value. For example, here is a magic square found using that algorithm.

1 12 5 16 15 9 8 2 14 6 11 3 4 7 10 13

In this case the first random value found was 5. It was randomly placed in the first row. Notice this is

different from how the other two algorithms work. 12 is the value that pairs with 5 to get to 17 so we place

12 randomly in one of the remaining open positions. The next random number found was 1 and it was placed

randomly in one of the remaining positions and then its pair, 16, was placed in the only remaining spot in the

first row.

This algorithm performs considerably better than the previous algorithm, requiring on average of only

about 600,000 tries to find a solution.

I look forward to your thoughts about other general algorithms that will allow us to find magic squares

for even larger n’s.

Below is an outline of the class and the methods that need to be implemented for that class. Do not make

any changes to the classes, variables, names, etc. Just add code. Questions? Start or continue a Discussion.

This assignment is as much about following instructions as it is about programming. Be sure your

methods do exactly what is expected of them and all rules mentioned below and in Canvas and class

discussions are followed.

What follows are general rules that you must follow for this and, as applicable, all other programs you

write in this class. Failure to follow these rules will cost you points.

1. I will eventually post a final test program. A sample test program is already posted to help get you

started. Don’t wait for my final test program to appear to start debugging your program. You should

begin testing with your own test programs. Also, the final test program I post may not be the same test

program I run on your programs. You cannot assume your program is correct just because it works on the

posted test program.

2. Submit your program through Canvas with the name prog1.java. Be sure that my main (test) program is

in a different file from your class(es) and you should not submit my test program. Also, do not make your

classes “public”. If you deviate from any of these rules you will lose points because doing so makes it

much more difficult for me to manage and test your programs.

3. The top of your prog1.java file (and all java code that you turn in to me in the future) should begin with

comments that show: (i) Your name; (ii) Comp 282 and clear mention of what time your class meets; (iii)

The assignment number; (iv) The date the assignment was handed in (which is not necessarily the same

as the due date); (v) A brief description of what is contained in the file.

4. For all Java code you turn in:

a) Choose clear and suggestive variable names.

b) Be sure lines do not wrap to the first column of the next line or disappear off the end of the page.

c) Use comments generously to describe how your methods work. Comments should appear

inside your methods, too – not just at the top. That said, don’t overdo the comments.

d) There should be no more than one return statement in any method.

e) Do not use break statements to exit loops.

f) Do not use global variables. If you are not sure if you are using them, ask.

g) Programs should be 100% your own work, as stated in the syllabus